Why Does My Pregnancy Test Say Positive and Negative? The Complete Guide

You stare at the two tests on the bathroom counter, your heart caught in a tug-of-war of emotions. One test clearly shows two lines, a plus sign, or the unmistakable word "Pregnant." The other, taken perhaps hours or a day later, displays a stark single line, a negative sign, or a "Not Pregnant" message. The whiplash is real and utterly confusing. Why does my pregnancy test say positive and negative? This scenario is more common than you might think, and the answers lie in a fascinating interplay of biology, chemistry, and timing. Before you spiral into a vortex of anxiety or uncertainty, know that conflicting results are a puzzle with several possible solutions, and this guide will walk you through each one.

The Foundation: How Home Pregnancy Tests Actually Work

To unravel the mystery of conflicting results, you first need to understand what these little sticks are actually detecting. Home pregnancy tests are designed to identify the presence of a specific hormone in your urine: human chorionic gonadotropin, universally known as hCG.

This hormone is your body's pregnancy announcement. It's produced by the cells that will eventually form the placenta, almost immediately after a fertilized egg attaches to the uterine lining (a process called implantation). In a very early pregnancy, the level of hCG in your body doubles approximately every 48 to 72 hours. It starts very low and rises rapidly, peaking around the 8th to 11th week of pregnancy before declining and leveling off.

Every pregnancy test has a built-in sensitivity level, measured in milli-international units per milliliter (mIU/mL). This number represents the minimum concentration of hCG it can detect. For example, a test with a sensitivity of 25 mIU/mL requires less hCG to return a positive result than one with a sensitivity of 50 mIU/mL. This fundamental principle is the key to understanding many conflicting results.

The Evaporation Line: A Classic Culprit for False Hope

One of the most frequent reasons for a confusing "maybe" result is misinterpreting an evaporation line, or "evap line." This is not a true positive result but a common pitfall of urine-based tests.

How it happens: After you use the test, the urine travels across a window containing the reactive chemicals. Once the urine evaporates, a faint, colorless, or sometimes grayish line can appear in the test window where the positive line would be. This is a residue left behind, not a chemical reaction to hCG.

How to spot it: Evap lines typically appear after the test's designated reading time (often 3-5 minutes, but always check your specific test's instructions). They are usually starkly different from a true positive line, which has color and thickness, and appears within the time frame. A good rule of thumb is to never read a test after the time limit stated in the instructions. What looks like a faint positive at 10 minutes might just be an evap line.

The Chemical Pregnancy: A Early Loss

This is a deeply significant and often misunderstood reason for a positive-then-negative sequence. A chemical pregnancy is a very early miscarriage that happens just after implantation, often before or around the time of your expected period.

Here’s the sequence of events:

Fertilization and implantation occur.
The developing embryo produces enough hCG to be detected by a sensitive test, resulting in a positive result.
For reasons often related to chromosomal abnormalities, the pregnancy does not progress.
The body stops producing hCG.
A subsequent test, taken a few days later, will show negative or much fainter results as hCG levels drop.

It's crucial to understand that a chemical pregnancy is a real pregnancy and a real loss, even though it occurs very early. They are remarkably common—some estimates suggest they account for 50-75% of all miscarriages. Many people experience them without even realizing it, simply assuming their period was a few days late. If you suspect this is the case, it's important to be gentle with yourself and know that it is not your fault and is rarely an indicator of future fertility problems.

Testing Too Early: The Timing Trap

In the age of "early result" tests, the urge to test days before a missed period is powerful. However, this is a prime scenario for getting a negative result followed later by a positive.

Imagine implantation happens on day 20 of your cycle. Your hCG level might be at 5 mIU/mL that day. The next day, it doubles to 10. The following day, it's at 20. If your test requires a level of 25 to be positive, testing on that third day will yield a negative. You might assume you're not pregnant. But if you wait two more days, your level could be 80 mIU/mL—more than enough to trigger a clear positive on the same test.

The golden rule: The first day of your missed period is the best time to test for the most accurate result. Even better, wait a few days after your missed period. If you get a negative but your period still doesn't arrive, test again in a few days.

Urine Concentration: The Dilution Effect

The concentration of your urine plays a huge role in test accuracy. Your first-morning urine is almost always the most concentrated, containing the highest level of hCG if you are pregnant.

Consider this scenario: You take a test first thing in the morning with your concentrated urine. It picks up on the low-but-present hCG and shows a faint positive. Elated, you decide to test again later in the afternoon to "see the line get darker." But you've been drinking water and coffee all day, diluting your urine. The hCG is now spread out in a larger volume of liquid, and its concentration falls below the test's detection threshold. The afternoon test comes back negative, creating confusion and worry.

For the most reliable results, especially early on, always use your first-morning urine. If you must test later in the day, try to hold your urine for at least 3-4 hours to allow hCG to build up again.

User Error and Test Variability

While modern tests are highly accurate when used perfectly, human error is always a factor.

Not following instructions: Did you hold the stick in the stream for the exact number of seconds? Did you dip it for the right amount of time? Did you read it within the time window?
Expired or faulty tests: Always check the expiration date on the box. Tests that have been stored in a humid bathroom or in extreme temperatures can also degrade and become unreliable.
Using different brands: As mentioned, tests have different sensitivities. A positive on a super-sensitive "early detection" test followed by a negative on a less-sensitive standard test is entirely possible.

Underlying Medical Conditions

While less common, certain medical conditions can also interfere with hCG levels and test results.

Ectopic Pregnancy: This is a dangerous condition where the embryo implants outside the uterus, often in a fallopian tube. In an ectopic pregnancy, hCG levels often rise, but typically slower and lower than in a healthy uterine pregnancy. This can lead to faint positives or fluctuating results. If you have a positive test and experience sharp abdominal pain, shoulder pain, or dizziness, seek immediate medical attention.
Medications: Fertility treatments containing synthetic hCG (like a "trigger shot") can cause a false positive if tested too soon after the injection. Other medications like anticonvulsants, diuretics, or tranquilizers have been known to interfere, but this is rare.
Medical conditions: Very rarely, certain cancers, ovarian cysts, or pituitary gland issues can cause elevated hCG levels in non-pregnant individuals.

What To Do Next: Your Action Plan for Conflicting Results

So, you're holding two tests that tell two different stories. What is your logical next step?

Don't Panic: Take a deep breath. You now have a list of possible explanations. The emotional rollercoaster is real, but you are gathering data.
Wait and Retest: The single best course of action is often to simply wait 48-72 hours. This allows time for your hCG levels to double if you are pregnant. Then, test again using your first-morning urine with a new, reliable test.
Call Your Healthcare Provider: This is always a valid and recommended option. Explain the situation. They can provide clarity and often order a quantitative hCG blood test. This test measures the exact amount of hCG in your bloodstream, providing a concrete number rather than a simple yes/no. Having this test done twice, 48 hours apart, will show if the levels are rising appropriately, which is the clearest indicator of a progressing early pregnancy.

The journey from wondering to knowing is filled with anticipation, hope, and sometimes, frustrating uncertainty. That seesaw of positive and negative results is not a definitive answer but a question in itself—a question about timing, biology, and the very delicate beginnings of potential new life. By understanding the science behind the stick, you transform confusion into empowered knowledge, ready to take the next step with clarity and confidence, whatever the outcome may be.

Back to blog